Senate Approves Comprehensive Opioid Addiction Legislation

March 16, 2016Adam Waters

Last week, the Senate passed the Comprehensive Addiction and Recovery Act (CARA, S. 524) on a 94 to 1 vote. CARA aims to address the growing opioid addiction problem in the United States by increasing the availability and efficacy of public health programs. In particular, the legislation would increase education about and access to medication-assisted treatment for opioid addiction, countering the existing trend to treat addiction through total abstinence from the illegal substance, and would provide grants to states and localities to develop alternatives to incarceration for individuals with substance abuse problems.

Proponents of CARA argue that the bill offers a broad, comprehensive approach to heroin and opioid abuse, combining prevention, law enforcement, public health, education and other strategies to increase the likelihood of successful anti-abuse interventions.

At the same time, CARA has come under criticism from a variety of sources. For example, Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH) initially criticized the bill for not providing adequate funding to fully respond to the opioid epidemic. She introduced an amendment to provide an emergency authorization of $600 million to the Department of Justice and the Department of Health and Human Services for opioid treatment programs, but ended up voting in favor of CARA even after the amendment was defeated.

Similarly, the White House proposed $1.1 billion in its Fiscal Year 2017 budget released in February to address the opioid epidemic, a much larger ask than what appears in the final version of CARA as passed by the Senate. While the administration’s plan contains significant differences in funding and strategy from the Senate bill, President Obama is expected to sign CARA if it reaches his desk.

The Reform Movement has long supported a nuanced approach to dealing with substance abuse. Grounded in our tradition’s teaching against the use of any substances that destroy the body, the Movement resolved in 1989 to “declare its unequivocal opposition to all forms of substance abuse” and to engage in efforts to rehabilitate individuals suffering from drug addictions. More recently, the URJ has voiced support for alternatives to incarceration for substance abuse.

CARA will now move on to the House of Representatives, where it is expected to face more significant opposition. Ultimately, whether through this bill, the President’s plan or some other form, it is imperative that our government address the crisis of opioid addiction in this country through a multi-pronged strategy of public health interventions and community support.

Photo courtesy of Flickr/e-Magine Art

Related Posts

The Importance of Black Maternal Health

Earlier this month, we attended the Black Maternal Health Week 2025 Congressional Briefing by the Black Maternal Health Federal Policy Collective and The Century Foundation. As soon as we walked in the room, we felt a sense of camaraderie and hope as we saw so many others passionate about maternal health.

URJ and Israel: Post-October 7th Updates and Resources

Our hearts are with the people of Israel and the civilians in Gaza at this difficult time. We pray for the immediate release of all of the hostages, a negotiated ceasefire, unimpeded humanitarian aid to innocent civilians in Gaza, and a future of safety and self-determination for both Israelis and Palestinians.

Justice Within Reach

We are excited to launch Justice Circles: Powered by the RAC. Learn how to start a Justice Circle and work with friends, family, and neighbors to make a difference.